Why I Fired Two Doctors

FiredDoctorsI really liked the OB/GYN practice I went to during my first pregnancy. Well, let me rephrase: I really liked the second practice I went to during my first pregnancy.

When I went to see my first OB/GYN, I was mostly happy with the practice. I had too long of a wait, of course, but the doctor seemed nice enough and answered all of my questions. So I kept going back for my monthly visits. But the doctor’s higher-than-average C-section rate kept ringing in my head. As did visions of the C-section knick-knacks he had on his shelves—little figurines of doctors pulling babies out of stomachs, I kid you not. I really wanted an unmedicated birth, and one of my biggest fears was an unnecessary C-section. So when someone recommended a doctor with a low C-section rate, I didn’t hesitate to make an appointment. It turned out I felt really comfortable there, so I switched at 20 weeks and rotated between the doctors in the practice, one of whom made it to the hospital for my speedy delivery.

When it came time to start my prenatal care for pregnancy No. 2, it was a no-brainer to head back to the doctor that delivered my daughter. And then at 6 weeks pregnant, on a Tuesday night, I started spotting. It was light, but I was very concerned, especially because nothing like that had happened during my first pregnancy. No matter how many stories I read on the internet about women who had first trimester spotting, it did nothing to ease my fears. So I did what you should do—I monitored the bleeding, which stopped after several hours, and called my doctor the following morning.

By Wednesday evening, I hadn’t gotten a return phone call from my doctor. It seemed odd, but I decided to give them the benefit of the doubt. When I hadn’t heard back by the next morning, I called again. I let them know that I’d called before and why, and was assured that the doctor would be arriving at any moment and would call me back. By that night? Not a peep. At that point, my husband and I were furious. Even if there was nothing they could do at that early stage of pregnancy—even if it was perfectly normal—we at least wanted to talk to my doctor about it.

So on Friday morning, I started making phone calls to find a new practice. The new doctor, who called me back personally, couldn’t believe that I’d been ignored. Because she couldn’t technically give me any advice because she wasn’t yet my doctor, she wanted me to call my doctor. So after my third bitchiest-yet phone call, she did finally call me back. Her excuse? She didn’t get my message Wednesday. She was in surgery all day Thursday. Well, it wasn’t comforting that a message like that got lost. And with three doctors on staff, shouldn’t someone have called me back? Shouldn’t they have a policy that if one doctor is unavailable, another doctor should step in for the patient’s sake? No excuse would have been enough at that point.

The medical community can be really intimidating. I think that as a patient—and maybe especially a pregnant patient—it’s so easy to feel stuck with a doctor you feel doesn’t really care. Whether you’re six weeks or 36 weeks pregnant or you just feel like your doctor, whether a podiatrist or dermatologist, doesn’t listen or doesn’t respond to your needs, don’t hesitate to switch. Find someone who makes you feel comfortable. After all, they work for you.

Have you ever had to switch doctors? What were the circumstances? —Erin


FTC disclosure: We often receive products from companies to review. All thoughts and opinions are always entirely our own. Unless otherwise stated, we have received no compensation for our review and the content is purely editorial. Affiliate links may be included. If you purchase something through one of those links we may receive a small commission. Thanks for your support!


Add a comment
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. SaraK says:

    Thanks for writing this post, Erin. I too switched doctors after my 20 week appt. I’d been going to the same gynecologist for 8+ years, but when I became pregnant my regular dr was not an OB. The practice was very large (13 drs) and they only delivered at one hospital that I didn’t want to go to. After 20 weeks when I knew everything was going well with the pregnancy, I switched to a midwifery practice and it was truly the best decision for me. I was able to have personalized prenatal care, I always felt in control of my decisions, and most importantly I was able to have the kind of delivery I was hoping for at a great hospital.

  2. Rebecca says:

    I’m so encouraged after reading this post! I just switched providers at about 33 weeks (yikes!). My original OB seemed fine (although I didn’t totally love the response she had with my questions about natural birth and even a water birth at the hospital) but she stayed on maternity leave longer than she originally told me 5 months ago and while the temp doc was okay, I didn’t feel right with her and had no interest in having her deliver my baby. My cousin recommended a particular midwife and so I made an appointment. I’m so glad I did! The one appointment I’ve had with her was so much better than all the previous ones at the other practice. Even though it was scary, I think it was definitely worth it to switch providers, even so late in a pregnancy.

  3. Heather says:

    I had to switch doctors because of an ongoing dispute between my insurance and the hospital where my OB delivered. I was really nervous to switch and wanted to wait it out to see if the dispute would be resolved, which it eventually was. However, I was recommended to another practice by a friend and made an appointment. It was the best decision I made and I love my OB and the hospital in delivered my son at!

  4. Amy says:

    I know as a former STNA that was my biggest thing was to speak to the nurses or even the doctor if possible to let them if the patient had concerns or even my self for the person. I think because of this I was probably impossible with the nurses I would radddle off everything I knew a nurse would ask. Most of the time they would be back to me with an hour. As bad as it is the medical field is a lot like other fields were you have to keep at it