9 Tricks for Containing Toy Clutter

We had an overflow of kids’ toys before Christmas. Now, things are out of control. New gifts and toys have flooded our house, and I feel like I’m drowning in battery-operated gizmos and gadgets. Even though I feel toy claustrophobia, I have a hard time getting rid of things. It’s a hoarder’s instinct. But I refuse to kick the New Year off with kid clutter up to my eyes, so here’s the method I’ve been using to get control over the past few days.


9 Tricks for Containing Toy Clutter

1. Forget Toy Story. Don’t anthropomorphize every toy in the house — they don’t have personalities; they don’t really come to life when you leave the room. Remember this so you can …

2. Be brutal. It’s easy to be sentimental over toys. First stuffed animals and well-worn toys weasel their way into your heart. But if they’ve since been relegated to the bottom of the toy bin and never see the light of day? You and your kids will forget about them as soon as they’re packed and purged. If you have a hard time being brutal …

3. Store toys “temporarily.” Pack toys up for the basement or storage closet. Then, you can either swap out toys so that the kids get “new” toys every now and then or, most likely, forget about these extras and decide you’re fine to part with them for good.

4. Ask: Do you have multiples? How many dolls do you have? Do you really need a hundred trains? Most likely culling a few from the bunch won’t be noticed.

5. Ask: Is it broken? If something is broken or has missing parts, toss!

6. Ask: Is it annoying? Does it make annoying sounds or play annoying songs? Do fights break out any time this toy makes an appearance? This is an easy call.

7. Ask: Do the kids care? Recruit the kiddos to pare down the toy stash. Sometimes they’re more ready to move on than you think. Once you’ve made some tough decisions …

8. Store like with like. Art supplies? Store them together. Keep puzzles in one place. Get a bin for cars or trains or blocks or character figures or Legos or dolls — and try to keep like items together as much as possible. It makes it easier for kids to know where to put them when they’re done playing, and it can help you see what’s being played with the most for the next purge party.

9. Donate or give. Knowing toys are being donated to a good cause or to someone who can use it can help assuage the guilt when you get rid of toys. Someone will get some good out of it!

Now that I have three kids, it’s tough for me to get rid of toys the baby might enjoy. But then I remind myself that she’ll have birthdays and Christmases, too …

What’s your favorite trick to cut the toy clutter? I personally love No. 3 because I rarely end up getting stuff back out! —Erin

FTC disclosure: We often receive products from companies to review. All thoughts and opinions are always entirely our own. Unless otherwise stated, we have received no compensation for our review and the content is purely editorial. Affiliate links may be included. If you purchase something through one of those links we may receive a small commission. Thanks for your support!